Visit Website →
← Back to blog

Ban the Box in Trucking: What Drivers and Service Providers Need to Know

October 20, 2026
Ban the Box in Trucking: What Drivers and Service Providers Need to Know

Ban the box limits when an employer may ask about criminal history. It does not remove the safety checks that federal rules require for commercial drivers. For trucking, that means two separate tracks: a fair chance process for criminal-record questions, and mandatory DOT and FMCSA qualification checks. Whether the first track is legally required depends on where you hire, because no single national law covers private trucking employers.

This guide is for two groups: FedEx Service Providers building a hiring process for linehaul, CDL-A team, CDL-A solo, and pickup and delivery roles, and drivers with a record who want to know what to expect.

Ucep
Find Drivers for FedEx Roles
UCEP connects FedEx Service Providers with drivers for linehaul, CDL-A team, CDL-A solo, and pickup and delivery roles.
Visit UCEP

TL;DR

  • Ban the box is a timing rule, not a hiring guarantee. It usually delays criminal-history questions until later in the process.
  • There is no federal ban the box law for private trucking employers. The federal Fair Chance Act covers federal agencies and contractors acting on their behalf. Private rules come from states and cities.
  • Fair chance hiring never replaces FMCSA requirements: the three-year driving record inquiry, prior-employer safety checks, and drug and alcohol verification still apply.
  • Service Providers hiring at several terminals should review each location's rules rather than use one national application template.
  • Drivers with a record should prepare a short, factual explanation, correct any errors, and apply where the role fits.

Table of Contents

What ban the box means

The name comes from the checkbox on job applications that asks whether you have been convicted of a crime. NCSL explains that these policies rest on the idea that an employer should consider a candidate's qualifications first, without the stigma of a conviction or arrest record. Many policies remove the history question from the application and move it to a later stage.

Three points define the concept:

  1. It changes when, not whether. An employer can often still review criminal history later, where the law allows.
  2. It does not promise a job. A conviction can still be a legitimate reason not to hire, if the employer assesses it properly.
  3. It varies by place. Coverage, trigger point, and exemptions differ across jurisdictions.

Is there a federal ban the box law?

Not for private trucking employers. The Fair Chance to Compete for Jobs Act applies to federal agencies and federal contractors acting on their behalf. OPM's final regulations took effect on October 2, 2023. They generally bar requesting criminal-history information before a conditional offer, with exceptions. They do not eliminate later background review where the law permits it.

Do not assume this rule reaches a company only because it does transportation work or has a commercial relationship with FedEx. Whether a specific contract qualifies is a legal question about that contract. If you are unsure, ask counsel.

Which states and cities have it

According to NCSL, Hawaii was the first state, in 1998. Twenty-six more states and Washington, D.C. have since adopted policies. Only 12 states plus D.C. extend them to private employers. The others cover public employment only. NCSL also notes that policies differ in:

  • which employers are covered;
  • whether the trigger is an interview or a conditional offer;
  • which jobs are exempt.

Cities and counties add their own rules, and the number of covered jurisdictions changes. Sources count them differently, so check a current, jurisdiction-level list before you rely on a figure. NCSL's criminal records enactment database is updated quarterly, and legislative activity on record barriers, licensing, and discrimination is continuing. That is why the topic is still relevant in 2026.

Why exemptions matter in trucking

Some laws exempt positions where federal or state law requires a background check or bars people with certain convictions from the job. Whether a given driving role falls under such an exemption depends on the statute in that state. Read the exemption language for your location instead of assuming trucking is exempt.

How state law determines trucking job exemptions

What the EEOC adds to the picture

Separate from any ban the box statute, federal anti-discrimination law applies to private employers. The EEOC's guidance on background checks explains that reviewing qualifications before criminal history lets an employer assess skills and experience first. Its small business guidance frames the central question: does this record predict responsible, reliable, and safe performance in this particular job?

Two practical consequences for hiring:

  • Blanket exclusions carry risk. A policy that rejects everyone with any record can create Title VII disparate-impact risk unless it is job-related and consistent with business necessity.
  • Arrests are not convictions. The EEOC's arrest and conviction resources say an arrest alone does not establish that someone committed a crime. Employers should treat arrests and convictions differently.

When a record might matter, the EEOC points employers to the nature of the offense, the time elapsed, and the duties of the job. Employers should also give the applicant a chance to explain.

What fair chance hiring does not replace

A driver job is a safety-sensitive job. A fair chance process sits beside the DOT framework and never substitutes for it. These are the checks that stay in place.

RequirementWhat it involvesSource
Driving record inquiryInquiry to licensing authorities covering the preceding three years49 CFR 391.23
Safety performance historyInvestigation with previous DOT-regulated employers, with good-faith efforts documented49 CFR 391.23
Investigation fileRecords placed in the driver investigation history file within 30 days after employment begins49 CFR 391.23
File retentionKept for the employment period and three years afterward49 CFR 391.53
Drug and alcohol record checkWritten consent, then a request for prior testing records before safety-sensitive work49 CFR 40.25

FMCSA's Pre-Employment Screening Program gives carriers crash and inspection data, and employers may use it as part of hiring. A driver who refuses the required consent for drug and alcohol checks cannot perform safety-sensitive functions.

For deeper detail on each piece, see our guides on CDL drug testing requirements for hiring, building a PSP report hiring workflow, MVR reports, and the DOT medical exam checklist.

A two-track hiring process for Service Providers

The cleanest way to stay compliant is to document two tracks and keep them from blurring.

Track one: fair chance handling of criminal history

  1. Check the location. For each terminal or delivery station, confirm whether a state or local law covers private employers and what its trigger point is.
  2. Edit the application. Remove the conviction question where the law requires it, or where you choose to delay it. Our list of driver application form field groups shows which sections an FMCSA-aligned form needs.
  3. Screen on qualifications first. Look at CDL class, endorsements, experience, and availability before any criminal-history review.
  4. Ask at the allowed stage. Run the background check at the point your jurisdiction permits, with the disclosures and consent your screening vendor and the Fair Credit Reporting Act require.
  5. Assess individually. Consider the offense, the time elapsed, and the job duties. Document the reasoning.
  6. Give a chance to respond. If a record may lead to rejection, let the applicant explain or correct it. Some jurisdictions require specific notice and adverse-action steps, so confirm yours.

Track two: DOT and FMCSA qualification

  1. Collect the application information the regulations require.
  2. Obtain the motor vehicle record and PSP data where you use it.
  3. Contact prior DOT-regulated employers and document good-faith attempts.
  4. Complete drug and alcohol record checks with written consent.
  5. Confirm the medical certification. See the DOT medical exam guide.
  6. Build the driver investigation history file and keep access restricted.

Track two is mandatory for every driver, whatever track one says. Track one varies by place.

Common errors to avoid

  • Using one national application template for terminals in different states.
  • Treating an arrest with no conviction as a disqualifier.
  • Rejecting automatically without an individual assessment.
  • Mixing criminal-history results into the DOT investigation file without a clear purpose.
  • Writing job ads that promise or imply things the law does not support. Our job ad compliance checklist covers three checks. Our guide to common mistakes hiring CDL drivers covers more.

How we see it

We built UCEP for FedEx Service Providers and the drivers who work with them, so we see both sides of this question. Most confusion comes from treating ban the box as one rule. It is a patchwork, and a Service Provider with terminals in several states is likely to meet several versions of it.

How we see it — overview diagram

Our view is practical. Keep the process simple enough that a dispatcher or recruiter can follow it every time: qualifications first, criminal-history review at the legally allowed stage, DOT checks for everyone, and a written reason for any decision. A documented process protects the Service Provider and gives drivers a fairer, more predictable path.

For drivers, the useful point is that a record does not close every door, and the rules that govern your application depend on where the job is. Read the job listing, check the location, and prepare your explanation before you apply.

— Aaron

If you are a driver with a record

The EEOC notes that employers may consider explanations, education, training, references, community support, and rehabilitative efforts. Preparation matters. Use this checklist.

  1. Know your record. Get a copy and confirm what it shows. Separate arrests from convictions.
  2. Correct errors. If something is wrong, ask for it to be corrected before you rely on the record in an application.
  3. Write a short, factual explanation. State the offense, the disposition, and the dates. Avoid excuses and keep it brief.
  4. Show what has changed. Include training, steady work history, and references.
  5. Be ready for the standard checks. Employers can review your motor vehicle record and safety history, and drug and alcohol compliance is required. Our MVR guide shows what appears there.
  6. Know that some restrictions are job-specific. Separate federal or state rules can limit certain roles. Ask the employer directly if you are unsure.
  7. Prepare for the interview. See how to prepare for a CDL driving job interview and what a trucking skills assessment covers.

License status can also limit what you can drive. Our article on why CDL-A drivers face license restrictions explains the common causes.

Drivers can browse CDL-A team, CDL-A solo, and pickup and delivery listings from FedEx Service Providers in one place, and research employers before applying.

Service Providers can post openings on UCEP and manage applicants with the built-in applicant tracking system. A complimentary trial listing is available for new recruiters, and the Standard Monthly Plan is $99 per month. See plans and pricing.

FAQ

What states have banned the box?

NCSL reports that Hawaii was first in 1998, and 26 more states plus Washington, D.C. have since adopted policies. Only 12 states plus D.C. apply them to private employers. Check the NCSL summary and the local rules for the hiring location.

Is ban the box a federal law?

Not for private employers. The federal Fair Chance Act covers federal agencies and the contractors acting on their behalf. A private trucking company is generally governed by state and local law, plus EEOC rules against discrimination.

Does ban the box mean a trucking company cannot run a background check?

No. It generally changes when criminal-history questions are asked. DOT-required checks, such as the driving record, prior employer safety history, and drug and alcohol verification, still apply to every driver.

Can a past conviction stop me from getting a CDL driving job?

It does not automatically disqualify you under general federal employment law. The employer should consider the offense, the time elapsed, and the job duties, and give you a chance to explain. Separate federal or state rules can still restrict specific roles, so ask the employer about your situation.

Sources